Kyngdom Digital All articles
Web Design

Rankings Won't Save You From a Demand Letter: The 10-Point Accessibility Audit to Run This Week

Kyngdom Digital
Rankings Won't Save You From a Demand Letter: The 10-Point Accessibility Audit to Run This Week

Photo: Rawpixel, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

The letter doesn't care about your traffic

It arrives as a PDF attached to an email from a law firm you've never heard of. It cites Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act and WCAG 2.1 AA, describes a handful of things your website allegedly does wrong, and asks for a settlement figure plus attorney fees — occasionally more than a small shop spends on marketing in a year.

These letters are not urban legend. Filing activity has clustered in a handful of states — New York, California, Florida, and Texas among them — and the targets are not just big retailers. The local dentist, the regional equipment dealer, the wedding venue, the self-storage operator: all have received them. The legal picture for private businesses is genuinely messy; there's still no finalized DOJ rule setting a specific technical standard for private sites, courts have split, and none of this column counts as legal advice. Talk to a lawyer about your specific situation.

But here's the part owners miss. By the time you're calling counsel, the technical work is already done being necessary. You can't rank your way out of this one.

Why accessibility is a quality signal, not a checkbox

Roughly one in four US adults lives with some form of disability, per CDC figures. Add the temporary and situational crowd — the broken wrist, the glare on the phone screen in a parking lot, the 61-year-old who has quietly started zooming every page to 150% — and the number of people who benefit from an accessible site gets close to everyone.

It also shows up in how the site performs. Captions and transcripts get indexed. Semantic HTML with real headings and labels reads better for every crawler, human or otherwise. Clean focus states and generous tap targets lift conversion on mobile. Accessible sites get faster, tidier, and easier to buy from, which is a nice side effect of trying to be decent.

Read it as a brand issue. A checkout that traps a keyboard user is a broken promise about how much you care, published at scale.

The failures that show up in complaints

The ten-point audit

  1. Unplug the mouse. Tab through your homepage, navigation, lead form, and checkout. Can you reach everything? Can you see where you are? Can you escape the modal?
  2. Check contrast. Run your body and button colors through the WebAIM Contrast Checker. Aim for 4.5:1 on body text and 3:1 on large text and UI edges.
  3. Inspect every form. Each input needs a visible label tied to the field in code. Error messages should say what's wrong in text, not just turn the border red.
  4. Write real alt text. Describe informative images in a sentence. Mark decorative ones as empty. Alt text that reads image of product is not alt text.
  5. Caption and transcribe. Every video gets captions; every audio clip gets a transcript. This is a small line item per piece of media and one of the highest-value fixes available.
  6. Kill auto-play with sound. If anything moves on its own, it needs a pause control and it must stop after five seconds.
  7. Audit headings. One H1 per page, a logical order beneath it, and no styled divs pretending to be headings.
  8. Zoom to 200%. Nothing should clip, overlap, or force sideways scrolling for blocks of text.
  9. Rewrite links. Use descriptive text that makes sense out of context.
  10. Run the machines, then use your eyes. axe DevTools, WAVE, and Lighthouse will catch a meaningful slice of issues — often cited as roughly a third. Then test with an actual screen reader. NVDA is free on Windows; VoiceOver ships with every Mac. Set aside twenty minutes and listen to your own checkout.

The math usually favors fixing

An automated first pass costs a few hours of a developer's time. Alt text and label fixes are minutes per element. Professional captions run a couple of dollars per minute of video. A navigation rework is a real project, but it's a project you may already be scheduling.

Compare that to a five-figure settlement, plus remediation, plus legal fees, plus the version of the story that reaches your reviews. Then compare it to the revenue from customers who currently abandon your site because it's unusable.

Stop re-litigating it every redesign

Put accessibility in the contract with your agency or developer. Add it to QA: does this release break keyboard navigation, contrast, or labels? Publish a short accessibility statement with a working feedback email — it costs nothing and shows good faith. And keep the audit on the calendar twice a year, because the fix you shipped in spring doesn't survive an autumn theme update.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Lead You'll Answer Tomorrow Already Called Someone Else: Making Response Time a Marketing KPI

The Lead You'll Answer Tomorrow Already Called Someone Else: Making Response Time a Marketing KPI

The Answer Engine Doesn't Know You Exist: A Visibility Audit for the AI Search Era

The Answer Engine Doesn't Know You Exist: A Visibility Audit for the AI Search Era

Doing Nothing Is a Pricing Decision: The Real Cost of Postponing Your Website Redesign

Doing Nothing Is a Pricing Decision: The Real Cost of Postponing Your Website Redesign